India Has a Good Constitution That's Often Been Let Down by Politicians and Judges

3 months ago 66

India has a good constitution that's often been let down by politicians and judges: former Judge of the Supreme Court, Justice Madan Lokur, to Karan Thapar for The Wire. .......................................... In an interview to discuss the Indian constitution, as it approaches its 75 anniversary tomorrow, 26th January, one of the most highly regarded former Judges of the Supreme Court has said that India has a good constitution but at critical moments it’s been let down by people whose job is to honour it i.e. the executive and the legislature, as well as by those whose duty is to defend it i.e. the judiciary. Justice Madan Lokur said B. R. Ambedkar was “spot on” when he said that a good constitution can be rendered a poor product if the men and women whose duty is to operate and defend it do so improperly or inadequately. In a 40-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, which covers a whole range of issues to do with the constitution, the praise its received and the criticism it’s had to defend itself against, Justice Lokur spoke both about Indira Gandhi’s dictatorial behaviour during the Emergency as well as similar aspects of behaviour from Narendra Modi in recent years. I don’t wish to precis or paraphrase Justice Lokur’s views because I think you should hear them in full for yourself. So I will stop there. What I will do instead is to give you the questions that were asked so that you can see the range of issues covered. Here they are:- 1) Tomorrow the Indian constitution will be 75 years old. Given that the global average lifespan of a constitution is 19 years and, second, none of the constitutions of our neighbouring countries has lasted anywhere as long, how significant a landmark is this? 2) Over the decades the constitution has had both its supporters and critics. Some scholars have criticized it for being colonial. The RSS claims it’s not rooted in an Indian ethos. But as you view the constitution has it been good for India? 3) Unlike Britain and America, the Indian constitution conferred Universal Adult Suffrage at one go, regardless of creed, class, caste, education or wealth. And that became the bedrock of India’s democracy. How significant is this? 4) Over the 75 years of its existence the constitution has been amended 106 times. Do you view that as a source of strength or proof of weakness? 5) Let’s come to some of the criticisms. First, it’s said that the constitution has strengthened the executive over the legislature, a tendency that’s been exacerbated by the 10th Schedule and the way Speakers have functioned. As a result, MPs have been subordinated to their party leadership and the Speaker doesn’t have the authority he would in the House of Commons. How do you respond to that? - “The Indian parliament was born a structurally weak institution, depending on the good will of the executive for its functioning”: Gautam Bhatia. 6) In this context let me cite what the scholar Gautam Bhatia has written (TOI): “The Indian constitution … conferred great power on the executive and trusted it to wield that power well, instead of putting structural constraints upon it.” Was the constitution mistaken in assuming our rulers would be good men who would always act within both the letter and the spirit of the constitution? 7) The constitution also created a federal structure but, again, it’s given the Centre overriding authority over the states, both financially and administratively as well as with the power to re-arrange the federal map as parliament wants. This may have been necessary at independence but is it still necessary three quarters of a century later? 8) Third, the constitution conferred several fundamental rights on Indian citizens but stopped short of an absolute right of freedom of speech and expression. In fact, free speech can be restricted on grounds of morality, defamation and, even, friendly relations with foreign states. Do those restrictions go too far? 9) Fourth, how do you view Indira Gandhi’s Emergency? It happened not by suspending the constitution or acting outside of it but by imposing the constitution’s own mechanisms. Did that expose a weakness or flaw in the constitution? Join The Wire's Youtube Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChWtJey46brNr7qHQpN6KLQ/join Join The Wire's Youtube Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChWtJey46brNr7qHQpN6KLQ/join

The Vision and Mission of Upilink News - Empowering Informed Citizens

Welcome to Upilink News, your gateway to unbiased news, investigative journalism, and a platform free from government censorship. At Upilink, we believe in the power of information to empower citizens, fostering a well-informed society capable of making informed decisions.

Our platform, hosted at www.news.upilink.in, is meticulously curated to provide users with a reliable source of news, steering clear of propaganda and ensuring the delivery of objective reporting.

The Need for Upilink News

In an era where information is abundant but often tainted with bias and misinformation, the need for a trustworthy news source has never been more critical. Upilink News recognizes this necessity and strives to fill the gap by offering a carefully curated selection of news from diverse, reputable sources.

Our commitment to unbiased reporting and investigative journalism distinguishes us as a beacon of truth in the digital news landscape.

Our Unique Approach

What sets Upilink News apart is our meticulous selection process for news sources.

We prioritize transparency, accountability, and reliability in our curation, ensuring that only the most credible and unbiased reports make it to our platform.

Our team of experienced journalists and fact-checkers work tirelessly to sift through the noise and present users with news that stands up to scrutiny.

The Role of Investigative Journalism

Investigative journalism is at the heart of Upilink News. We understand that a well-functioning democracy relies on an informed citizenry, and investigative reporting plays a pivotal role in uncovering the truth. By supporting and promoting investigative journalism, we aim to contribute to a more transparent and accountable society.

Sustaining Upilink News - Your Support Matters

Free Access for All

At Upilink News, we firmly believe that access to information should be a fundamental right for everyone. Therefore, our platform is entirely free to use, allowing users from all walks of life to stay informed without any financial barrier.

Donations - Fueling Independent Journalism

To sustain our commitment to unbiased reporting and investigative journalism, we rely on the generosity of our users. Your donations go directly towards supporting our team, maintaining our infrastructure, and enabling us to continually improve and expand our coverage.

By contributing, you become a vital part of the Upilink community, driving the mission to keep information free and accessible.

Advertisement - Balancing Sustainability

In addition to donations, we embrace advertisements as a means of generating revenue to support Upilink News.

In conclusion, Upilink News is more than just a news aggregator; it's a commitment to empowering citizens through unbiased information.

Join us in our mission, explore the diverse and credible news on our platform, and consider supporting us through donations. Together, let's build a community that values truth, transparency, and the power of an informed citizenry.